A “HOUSE PHILOSOPHER”? A NEW INTERPRETATION OF ONE ANCIENT RELIEF
Describing Pythagoras’ activities in Croton Iamblichus summarizes the content of his public speeches addressed to young men, to the Thousand who governed the city, as well as children and women of Croton. The earliest evidences about the Pythagoras’ speeches, available to us are found in an Athenian rhetorician and a pupil of Socrates Antisthenes (450–370 BCE), the historians Dicearchus and Timaeus, and Isocrates. In the present paper I consider the content of the Pythagoras’ speeches, preserved by Iamblichus, in more details, in order to suggest a new interpretation of the famous grave relief from the Antikensammlung, Berlin (Sk 1462). The relief, found in an “Olive grove on the road to Eleusis” and dated to the first century BCE, presents an image of a sitting half-naked bearded man with a young man, also half-naked, standing behind his chair, and a group of peoples consisting of a child, an older man and a woman, standing in front of him. Our attention attracts a big and clear image of the letter “Psi” above the scene. The comparison of the content of Pythagoras’ speeches with the picture given on the relief allows us to interpret the image as following: we suggest that the sitting man, undoubtedly a philosopher, could be a Pythagorean or Pythagoras himself; he is attended by his pupil and gives speeches to different groups of peoples, symbolically represented as a young man, a public agent, a woman and a child. Admittedly, the letter “Psi” symbolizes the Pythagorean teaching about psyche (the soul), and the relief itself, contrary to general opinion, was initially designed to adorn a school or a private building rather than a funeral monument. An alternative interpretation suggested is that the sitting figure could be a wandering physician.
Keywords: the images of philosophers, Pythagoras, plastic art, schools in antiquity, Asclepius
References:
Barney, Lewis, Beach 2006 – Barney S. A., Lewis I. W. J., Beach J. A. The Etymologies of Isidore of Seville. Oliver Berghof, 2006.
Cleland, Davies, Llewellyn-Jones 2007 – Cleland L., Davies G. and Llewellyn-Jones L. Greek and Roman dress from A to Z. Routledge, 2007.
Dekonsky, Rizhsky 2005 – Justin. Epitome of Pompeius Trogus “Historiae Philippicae”. Translation into Russian by А. А. Dekonsky, M. I. Rizhsky. Saint-Petersburg, 2005.
Deratani, Timofeeva 1965 – Readings in ancient literature. Vol. 2: Roman literature. Ed. by N. F. Deratani, N. A. Timofeeva. Moscow, 1965. In Russian.
Dillon, Hershbell 1991 – Iamblichus. On the Pythagorean Way of Life. Ed. J. Dillon, J. Hershbell. Atlanta, Georgia, 1991.
Frolov 2013 – Isocrates. Speeches. Letters. Ed. by E. D. Frolov. Translation into Russian by M. I. Botvinnik, A. I. Zaitseva and oth. Minor attic orators. Moscow, 2013.
Kharitonov 2006 – Isidore of Seville. The Etymologies or Origines. In XX books. Book I–III. Translation into Russian by L. A. Kharitonov. Saint-Petersburg, 2006.
Melnikova 2002 – Iamblichus. On the Pythagorean Way of Life. Translation into Russian by I. Yu. Melnikova. Moscow, 2002.
Norlin 1980 – Isocrates. In three volumes. Transl. by G. Norlin. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1980.
Rode 1901 – Rode Ε. Die Quellen des Jamblichus in seiner Biographie des Pythagoras. Kleine Schriften. Bd. 2. Tübingen, 1901.
Sebesta, Bonfante 1994 – The World of Roman costume. Ed. J. Sebesta, L. Bonfante. University of Wisconsin Press, 1994.
Smith, Wayte, Marindin 1890 – Smith W., Wayte W., Marindin G. E. A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities. 1890. E-version in the Perseus database.
Städele 1980 – Städele А. Die Briefe des Pythagoras und der Pythagoreer. Meisenheim a. Glan, 1980.
Velishsky 2000 – Velishsky F. History of Civilization: Life and manners of the ancient Greeks and Romans. Moscow, 2000. In Russian.
Zanker 1996 – Zanker P. The Mask of Socrates: The Image of the Intellectual in Antiquity. University of California Press, 1996.
Zelinsky 1990 – Sophocles. Drama. Sophocles Biography. Translation into Russian by F. F. Zelinsky. Moscow, 1990.
Zhmud 2012 a – Zhmud L. Pythagoras and the Early Pythagoreans. Oxford University Press, 2012.
Zhmud 2012 b – Zhmud L.Ya. Pythagoras and the early Pythagoreans. Moscow, 2012. In Russian.
( 1.68 MB ) 
( 1.67 MB )
Issue: 2, 2015
Series of issue: Issue 4
Rubric: ARTICLES
Pages: 44 — 54
Downloads: 1252