HISTORICAL MEMORY ABOUT ALEXANDER NEVSKY: SCULPTURAL VISUALIZATION
DOI: 10.23951/2312-7899-2021-1-95-123
The origins of the later versions of Alexander Nevsky’s sculptural visualization were laid back in ancient times. It is important that, in the pre-Petrine era, the icon-painting canon mainly provided for the image of Nevsky as a schemamonk, but it was not the only possible one. It has been established with a high degree of certainty that the first image of Alexander that came to us is the previously non-attributed figure represented on the icon “Our Lady of Tikhvin with the Proto-Gospel Cycle and Saints” (first half of the 16th century). The change of the icon-painting canon to the “secular” version (1724) had objective prerequisites, since, before that, Alexander had been depicted in princely robes in monumental painting, miniatures, on hagiographic icons. The fresco from Saint Sophia Cathedral in Vologda has a “transitional” nature. The creation of the first sculpture of Alexander Nevsky (the “chest statue”, 1754) is associated with the name of Mikhail Lomonosov; two portraits of Nevsky also come from his mosaic workshop. This sculpture was preceded by a bas-relief portrait of Nevsky on his shrine (1747–1752, State Hermitage, St. Petersburg). In the 19th century, statues of Nevsky were erected on the southern gates of St. Isaac's Cathedral in St. Petersburg (I.P. Vitali, 1841–1846) and on the monument “1000th Anniversary of Russia” in Veliky Novgorod (M.O. Mikeshin, I.N. Schroeder, 1862). In the post-revolutionary era, the government refused to use the old symbols in ideological settings, and the hero of the Neva battle was forgotten. The renaissance occurred after the release of the film Alexander Nevsky by Sergei Eisenstein. This led to the emergence of a new version of the visualization of the prince – in the image of Nikolay Cherkasov. In the postwar years, this version was also reflected in sculpture (a monument in Pereslavl-Zalessky). However, in the Russian Empire and in the Soviet Union, too few sculptural images of the prince were created. Using the installation of a stele in Ust-Izhora (Archive of the St. Petersburg House of Scientists) as an example, it is shown that the reconciling of even small commemorative plaques was extremely difficult. Since the early 1990s, the situation has changed. Monuments to the prince and sculptural compositions associated with his name appeared in many cities of the country, which makes the task of typologizing them urgent. The earliest type is a “chapel”. It is a vertical architectural plastic composition completed with a “dome” and a cross. The prince himself is represented in the image of a warrior (Pushkin, Ust-Izhora, Kobyl’ye Gorodishche, partly the Leninskoye village). One more type adjoins these monuments – a “monk” (Gorodets). The sculptural images of this type can be correlated with samples of the icon-painting tradition, both of the pre-Petrine (“monk”, the scenes of life of hagiographic icons) and Petrine (“holy warrior”) eras, and with miniatures of illustrated chronicles. The remaining types of monuments represent Nevsky in the image of a warrior, in which the attributes of his holiness, with rare exceptions, play a secondary role. First of all, this refers to equestrian monuments (Pskov (Sokolikha Mountain), St. Petersburg (Alexander Nevsky Square), etc.). The article shows the relationship of these works with domestic and foreign artistic traditions. A widespread type of monuments to Alexander Nevsky is a sculpture in the form of a single figure (Gorodets, Kursk, Volgograd, Vladimir, etc.). Despite the fact that in most cases the connection with visualization trends that come from the depths of centuries is minimized in this type, it can still be traced, first of all, through elements of Orthodox symbolism. Only two monuments of this type – in Petrozavodsk and Alexandrov – represent Alexander Nevsky in the image of both a warrior and a saint.
Keywords: Alexander Nevsky, history of Russia, historical memory, Russian culture, history of sculpture, history of Russian art
References:
Ackerman, J. S. (1957). Marcus Aurelius on the Capitoline Hill. Renaissance News, 10(2), 69–75.
Anon. (1869). Stroganovskiy ikonopisnyy litsevoy podlinnik kontsa XVI—nachala XVII stoletiya [Stroganovsky illustrated iconographic script of the end of the 16th — beginning of the 17th century]. Izdanie litografiy pri khudozhestvenno-promyshlennom muzeume.
Anon. (1873). Ikonopisnyy podlinnik novgorodskoy redaktsii po Sofiyskomu spisku kontsa XVI veka s variantom iz spiskov Zabelina i Filimonova [The icon-painting original of the Novgorod edition according to the Sofia list of the end of the 16th century with a version from the lists of Zabelin and Filimonov]. Universitetskaya tip.
Anon. (1878). Opisanie dokumentov i del, khranyashchikhsya v arkhivakh Svyateyshego Sinoda [Description of documents and cases stored in the archives of the Holy Synod]. Vol. III (Columns CXXXI–CLII). Sinodal’naya tip.
Bakhrushin, S. V. (Ed.) (1950). Dukhovnye i dogovornye gramoty velikikh i udel’nykh knyazey XIV-XVI vv. [Spiritual and contractual letters of the great and appanage princes of the 14th–16th centuries]. Vol. 4 (pp. 15–19). USSR AS.
Banige, V. S., & Pertsev, N. V. (1970). Vologda. Iskusstvo. (In Russian).
Begunov, Yu. K. (1966). Obraz Aleksandra Nevskogo v stankovoy zhivopisi XVII v. [The image of Alexander Nevsky in easel painting of the 17th century]. In I. P. Eremin (Ed.), Trudy Otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Old Russian Literature]. Vol. XXII (pp. 311–327). USSR AS.
Begunov, Yu. K. (1995). Aleksandr Nevskiy i sovremennost’ [Alexander Nevsky and the present]. In Yu. K. Begunov, & A. N. Kirpichnikov (Eds.), Knyaz’ Aleksandr Nevskiy. Materialy nauchno-prakticheskikh konferentsiy 1989 i 1994 gg. [Prince Alexander Nevsky. Conference proceedings in 1989 and 1994] (pp. 42–48). Tosnenskaya tip.
Begunov, Yu. K., & Kirpichnikov, A. N. (Eds.) (1995). Knyaz’ Aleksandr Nevskiy i ego epokha. Issledovaniya i materialy [Prince Alexander Nevsky and his era. Studies and materials]. (pp. 190–203). Dmitriy Bulanin.
Bergstein, M. (2002). Donatello’s “Gattamelata” and Its Humanist Audience. Renaissance Quarterly, 55(3), 833–868.
Bertash, A., & Talalay, M. (2016). Khristianskie obrazy v gorodskom ubranstve Sankt-Peterburga [Christian images in the urban decoration of St. Petersburg]. LIK.
Bischoff, I. (1965). Etienne Maurice Falconet-Sculptor of the Statue of Peter the Great. The Russian Review, 24(4), 369–386.
Department of Manuscripts of the Russian National Library. Fund 322 (Kablukov, S. P. Dnevnik 1917 g. [Diary of 1917]). File 45.
Department of the Orthodox Confession of the Russian Empire. (1875). Polnoe sobranie postanovleniy i rasporyazheniy po vedomstvu Pravoslavnogo ispovedaniya Rossiyskoy imperii [Complete collection of decrees and orders for the Department of the Orthodox Confession of the Russian Empire]. Vol. III. Sinodal’naya tip.
Department of the Orthodox Confession of the Russian Empire. (1876). Polnoe sobranie postanovleniy i rasporyazheniy po vedomstvu Pravoslavnogo ispovedaniya Rossiyskoy imperii [Complete collection of decrees and orders for the Department of the Orthodox Confession of the Russian Empire]. Vol. IV. Sinodal’naya tip.
Dolgov, V. V. (2015). Aleksandr Nevskiy [Alexander Nevsky]. Voprosy istorii, 10, 17–36.
Dolgov, V. V. (2016). Biografiya Aleksandra Nevskogo v zerkale “istoricheskogo narrativa” [Biography of Alexander Nevsky in the mirror of “historical narrative”]. In A. V. Petrov (Ed.), Drevnyaya Rus’: vo vremeni, v lichnostyakh, v ideyakh: Al’manakh [Ancient Russia: In time, in personalities, in ideas: Almanac]. Vol. 5 (pp. 190–212). St. Petersburg.
Evdokimova, S. (2006). Sculptured History: Images of Imperial Power in the Literature and Culture of St. Petersburg (From Falconet to Shemiakin). The Russian Review, 65(2), 208–229.
Filyushkin, A. I. (2017). Mesta pamyati ili pamyat’ mesta? Dve bitvy Aleksandra Nevskogo v istoricheskoy pamyati [Places of memory or memory of a place? Two battles of Alexander Nevsky in historical memory]. Dialog so vremenem, 60, 25–44.
Golubinskiy, E. E. (1998). Istoriya kanonizatsii svyatykh v Russkoy Tserkvi [History of the canonization of saints in the Russian Church]. Krutits.
Grosskurth, B. (2000). Shifting Monuments: Falconet’s Peter the Great between Diderot and Eisenstein. Oxford Art Journal, 23(2), 31–48.
Kachalova, I. Ya., Mayasova, N. A., & Shchennikova, L. A. (1990). Blagoveshchenskiy sobor Moskovskogo Kremlya [Annunciation Cathedral of the Moscow Kremlin]. Iskusstvo.
Klautova, O. Yu. (1993). Zhest v drevnerusskoy literature i ikonopisi XI-XIII vv. K postanovke voprosa [Gesture in Old Russian literature and icon painting of the 11th–13th centuries. To the formulation of the question]. In V. P. Adrianova-Peretts (Ed.), Trudy Otdela drevnerusskoy literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Old Russian Literature]. Vol. XXII (pp. 256–269). USSR AS.
Klemeshov, A. S. (2010). Pamyatniki Aleksandru Nevskomu [Monuments to Alexander Nevsky]. In A. V. Torkunov (Ed.), Aleksandr Nevskiy: gosudar’, diplomat, voin [Alexander Nevsky: Sovereign, diplomat, warrior] (pp. 335–358). R-Valent.
Kuchkin, V. A. (1990). Mongolo-tatarskoe igo v osveshchenii drevnerusskikh knizhnikov (XIII – pervaya chetvert’ XIV vv.) [The Mongol-Tatar yoke in the coverage of ancient Russian scribes (13th – first quarter of the 14th centuries)]. In Russkaya kul’tura v usloviyakh inozemnykh nashestviy i voyn. X – nachalo XX vv. [Russian culture in the conditions of foreign invasions and wars. The 10th – early 20th centuries]. Vol. I (pp. 15–69). Institute of Russian History.
Kvlividze, N. V. (2010). Ikonografiya Aleksandra Nevskogo [Iconography of Alexander Nevsky]. In A. V. Torkunov (Ed.), Aleksandr Nevskiy: gosudar’, diplomat, voin [Alexander Nevsky: Sovereign, diplomat, warrior] (pp. 267–284). R-Valent.
Lomonosov, M. V. (1959). Poln. sobr. soch.: V 11 t. [Complete works: In 11 volumes]. Vol. VIII. USSR AS.
Mansikka, V. P. (1913). Zhitie Aleksandra Nevskogo: Razbor redaktsiy i teksty [Life of Alexander Nevsky: Analysis of editions and texts]. Obshchestvo lyubiteley drevney pis’mennosti.
Marquand, A. (1920). The Equestrian Statue of Bartolommeo Colleoni. Art & Life, 11(7), 378–381.
Mel’nikov, V. (1997). Eka eklektika! [What eclecticism!]. Nevskoe vremya, 2 August.
Mezzatesta, M. P. (1984). Marcus Aurelius, Fray Antonio de Guevara, and the Ideal of the Perfect Prince in the Sixteenth Century. The Art Bulletin, 66(4), 620–633.
Nesterenko, A. N. (2017). Lozhnye narrativy biografii Aleksandra Nevskogo v otechestvennoy istoriografii [False narratives of the biography of Alexander Nevsky in Russian historiography]. Voprosy istorii, 1, 103–114.
Nikitina, T. L. (2006). Traditsionnoe i individual’noe v monumental’nykh rospisyakh Dmitriya Grigor’eva Plekhanova [The traditional and the individual in the monumental paintings of Dmitry Grigoriev Plekhanov]. X nauchnye chteniya pamyati Iriny Petrovny Bolottsevoy [X scientific readings in memory of Irina Petrovna Bolotseva] (pp. 33–40). Avers Press.
Potresov, A. S. (2019). Glavnyy simvol Pskova. Istoriya monumenta v pamyat’ Ledovogo poboishcha na gore Sokolikha v vospominaniyakh, dokumentakh, pis’makh, fotografiyakh i risunkakh [The main symbol of Pskov. The history of the monument in memory of the Battle on the Ice on Mount Sokolikha in memoirs, documents, letters, photographs and drawing]. Samolva; Pal’mir.
Proskurina, V. (2011). Creating the Empress: Politics and Poetry in the Age of Catherine II (pp. 109–149). Academic Studies Press.
Rogov, A. I. (1966). Aleksandr Nevskiy i bor’ba russkogo naroda s nemetskoy feodal’noy agressiey v drevnerusskoy pis’mennosti i iskusstve [Alexander Nevsky and the struggle of the Russian people with the German feudal aggression in ancient Russian writings and art]. In V. D. Korolyuk (Ed.), “Drang nakh Osten” i istoricheskoe razvitie stran Tsentral’noy, Vostochnoy i Yugo-Vostochnoy Evropy [“Drang nach Osten” and the historical development of the countries of Central, Eastern and South-Eastern Europe] (pp. 32–58). Nauka.
Ryabov, A.N. (2018). Aleksandr Nevskiy. Pamyatnye mesta [Alexander Nevskiy. Memorable places]. Gorodetskiy Gubernskiy kolledzh.
Saenkova, E. M. (2017). Ikona “Bogomater Tikhvinskaya s protoevangel’skim tsiklom i svyatymi” vtoroy chetverti XVI veka iz sobraniya Konstantina Voronina [The Icon “Our Lady of Tikhvin with the Proto-Gospel Cycle and Saints” of the second quarter of the 16th century from the collection of Konstantin Voronin]. In Sobranie Konstantina Voronina. Ikony. Khudozhestvennyy metall XIII-XVI veka [Collection of Konstantin Voronin. Icons. Artistic metalwork of the 13th–16th centuries] (pp. 54–66). Moscow.
Shaposhnik, V. V. (2015). Ivan Groznyy [Ivan the Terrible]. Akademiya issledovaniy kul’tury.
Shenk, F. B. (2007). Aleksandr Nevskiy v russkoy kul’turnoy pamyati. Svyatoy, pravitel’, natsional’nyy geroy. (1263–2000) [Alexander Nevsky in Russian Cultural Memory. Saint, ruler, national hero. (1263–2000)]. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
Shlyapkin, I. A. (1915). Ikonografiya svyatogo blagovernogo velikogo knyazya Aleksandra Nevskogo [Iconography of Holy Noble Grand Duke Alexander Nevsky]. Tip. M. A. Aleksandrova.
Sirenov, A. V. (2010). Stepennaya kniga i russkaya istoricheskaya mysl’ XVI–XVIII v. [The degree book and Russian historical thought of the 16th–18th centuries]. Al’yans-Arkheo.
Sirenov, A. V. (2016). The legitimation of the image of the Saint: On the issue of the authenticity of the relics of Alexander Nevsky. Studia Slavica et Balcanica Petropolitana, 1(19), 100–109.
Sizov, E.S. (1969). “Voobrazheny podobiya knyazey”. Stenopis’ Arkhangel’skogo sobora Moskovskogo Kremlya [“The images of princes are imagined.” Mural painting of the Arkhangelsk Cathedral of the Moscow Kremlin]. Avrora.
Smirnova, E. S., Laurina, V. K., & Gordienko, E. A. (1982). Zhivopis’ Velikogo Novgoroda. XV v. [Painting of Veliky Novgorod. The 14th century]. Nauka.
Sokolov, R. A. (2018). K voprosu ob ustanovke stely na meste Nevskoy bitvy 1240 g. [On installing a stele on the site of the Battle of the Neva in 1240]. In Yu. V. Krivosheev, & N. V. Shtykov (Eds.), Povest’ vremennykh let: k 900-letiyu sozdaniya [Tale of Bygone Years: To the 900th anniversary of its creation] (pp. 292–299). Izd-vo Olega Abyshko.
Sokolov, R. A., & Meshchenina, A. A. (2018). Istoricheskaya pamyat’ ob Aleksandre Nevskom v epokhu Petra I i ego preemnikov [Historical memory of Alexander Nevsky in the era of Peter I and his successors]. Canadian-American Slavic Studies, 52(4), 369–385.
Spiridonova, E. K. (2014). Vskrytie moshchey Aleksandra Nevskogo v 1922 godu (po materialam periodicheskoy pechati) [The autopsy of the relics of Alexander Nevsky in 1922 (based on materials from periodicals)]. Aleksandr Nevskiy i Ledovoe poboishche. Materialy nauchnoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy 770-letiyu Ledovogo poboishcha [Alexander Nevsky and the Battle of the Ice. Proceedings of the conference dedicated to the 770th anniversary of the Battle on the Ice] (pp. 155–159). Akademiya issledovaniya kul’tury.
Tseplyaev, A. A. (2011). Konnaya skul’ptura Sankt-Peterburga [The equestrian sculpture of St. Petersburg]. Rostok.
Uspenskiy, A.I. (Ed.) (1893). Podlinnik ikonopisnyy [The iconographic script]. Izd. S. T. Bol’shakova.
Valk, D. N. (Ed.) (1949). Gramoty Velikogo Novgoroda i Pskova [Charters of Veliky Novgorod and Pskov]. Vol. 2 (pp. 10–11). USSR AS.
Yanin, V. L. (2004). Srednevekovyy Novgorod. Ocherki arkheologii i istorii [Medieval Novgorod. Essays on archeology and history] (pp. 245–253). Nauka.
Zolotonosov, M. (2005). Bronzovyy vek. Illyustrirovannyy katalog pamyatnikov, pamyatnykh znakov, gorodskoy i dekorativnoy skul’ptury Leningrada-Peterburga 1985–2003 gg. [The Bronze Age. An illustrated catalog of monuments, memorial signs, urban and decorative sculpture of Leningrad-Petersburg. 1985–2003]. Novyy Mir Iskusstva.
( 794.13 kB ) 
( 783.46 kB )
Issue: 1, 2021
Series of issue: Issue 1
Rubric: ARTICLES
Pages: 95 — 123
Downloads: 970