SHINE AND POVERTY OF SEMANTIC PLATONISM

Nekhaev Andrei V.

DOI: 10.23951/2312-7899-2022-3-118-126

Information About Author:

Andrei V. Nekhaev, Tomsk Scientific Center, Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Russian Federation. University of Tyumen, Russian Federation. Omsk State Technical University, Russian Federation. E-mail: a.v.nekhaev@utmn.ru

The article presents criticism of Katz’s proto-theory. Based on the principles of semantic Platonism, he offers a new understanding of the relationship between sense and reference. However, his account faces three strong objections: against non-causal ways of accessing abstract Platonic entities (Benacerraf–Field–Cheyne), against intuition as the faculty to a priori knowledge of grammar facts (Horwich–Cheyne–Oliver), and against the medial status of finite intensionals in matters for fixing the reference of linguistic expressions (Kripke–Boghossian–Kush). Without convincing answers to these objections, Katz’s proto-theory cannot be considered as a fit competitor to naturalistic theories of language.

Keywords: Katz, sense, reference, abstract object, semantic Platonism

References:

Benacerraf, P. (1973). Mathematical Truth. The Journal of Philosophy, 70(19), 661–679.

Boghossian, P. (1993). Sense, Reference and Rule-Following. Philosophical Issues, 4, 135–141.

Cheyne, C. (1997). Getting in Touch with Numbers: Intuition and Mathematical Platonism. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 57(1), 111–125.

Cheyne, C. (1998). Existence Claims and Causality. Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 76(1), 34–47.

Cheyne, C. (2001). Knowledge, Cause, and Abstract Objects: Causal Objections to Platonism. Springer.

Field, H. (1989). Realism, Mathematics and Modality. Blackwell.

Frege, G. (2000a). Logika. Vvedenie [Logic. Introduction]. In Z. A. Kuzicheva (Ed.), Logika i logicheskaya semantika. Sbornik trudov [Logic and logical semantics. Collected works] (pp. 307–325). Translated from German by B. V. Birykov. Aspekt Press.

Frege, G. (2000b). O smysle i znachenii [On sense and linguistic meaning]. In Z. A. Kuzicheva (Ed.), Logika i logicheskaya semantika. Sbornik trudov [Logic and logical semantics. Collected works] (pp. 230–246). Translated from German by B. V. Birykov. Aspekt Press.

Hart, W. D. (1977). Review on “Mathematical Knowledge” by Mark Steiner. The Journal of Philosophy, 74(2), 118–129.

Horwich, P. (1993). Meaning and Metaphilosophy. Philosophical Issues, 4, 153–158.

Horwich, P. (2003). The Philosophy of Jerrold Katz. Philosophical Forum, 34(3/4), 225–232.

Katz, J. (1981). Language and Other Abstract Objects. Blackwell.

Katz, J. (1986). Why Intensionalists Ought Not Be Fregeans. In E. LePore (Ed.), Truth and Interpretation: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson (pp. 59–91). Basil Blackwell.

Katz, J. (1990). The Metaphysics of Meaning. MIT Press.

Katz, J. (1993). Précis of ”The Metaphysics of Meaning“. Philosophical Issues, 4, 128–134.

Katz, J. (1998). Realistic Rationalism. MIT Press.

Kripke, S. (2010). Wittgenstein on rules and private language. Kanon+. (In Russian).

Kusch, M. (2006). A Sceptical Guide to Meaning and Rules. Acumen.

Liggins, D. (2006). Is There a Good Epistemological Argument Against Platonism? Analysis, 66(2), 135–141.

Oliver, A. (2000). A Realistic Rationalism? Inquiry, 43(1), 111–135.

Parsons, C. (1980). Mathematical Intuition. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 80(1), 145–168.

Picazo, G. (2021). The Long Shadow of Semantic Platonism, Part I: General Considerations. Philosophia, 49(4), 1427–1453.

Wittgenstein, L. (1994). Filosofskie raboty [Philosophical works] (part 1, pp. 75–319). Translated from German. Gnozis.

( 267.41 kB ) ( 262.46 kB )

Issue: 3, 2022

Series of issue: Issue 3

Rubric: ARTICLES. LANGUAGE MEANING AND LINGUISTIC REALISM IN CONTEXT OF ANALYTIC PHILOSOPHY

Pages: 118 — 126

Downloads: 598